A bull named Research

Hands up who views farmers as scientists? Despite our best efforts, most of us still associate ‘science’ with white coats, labs and passive, labyrinthine prose. And yet some farmers practice science. They develop experimental and observational techniques.

So said Louise Fortmann – a rural sociologist at the University of California, Berkeley – at the GCARD session ‘Open science’, which sought to showcase how agricultural and wider science can impact development.

“[Farmers] learn about soils by working with the same soils year after year,” said Fortmann. “They are civil scientists.”

Whether or not you agree with her, it was one of the few times – from my perspective at least – a speaker had sincerely placed farmers on an equal footing with researchers. Shame then, that the hall was so empty – this was what “experts” and participants alike needed to hear instead of rhetorical posturing.

“We need to get out of the lab, off the research station and into the field, and start talking to farmers in their own language,” Fortmann said. “I hope we can dispense with the silly and dangerous dichotomy between science and development.”

She made a plea to researchers. “[You] need to be humble and collaborate with local experts, treating them not as data sources but as colleagues with whom new research and knowledge will be created.”

Fortmann told the charming story of Mama Esther Mudoma, an African farmer who worked with CIAT scientist Robin Buruchara to develop a variety of bean resistant to root rot. Mudoma bought a bull with the money she made from selling the beans to neighbouring villages, and named him Research. “Why Research?” Buruchara asked.

“You came here, we did research together.”

Naomi Antony
Assistant news editor, SciDev.Net

3 Responses to A bull named Research

  1. Louise Fortman’s sentiments sound like they were taken right out of the mouth of the Chairman of a giant farmer association in Mali called ROPPA, who at the just concluded 2nd Africa Rice Congress told scientists that they too have a civic duty to ensure countries achieve food security. ” A scientist is first of all a citizen and must therefore come and interact with farmers in their fields,” said Hammadou Cissoko. He chided researchers who he said were only seen by farmers when developing projects for donor funding. “Thousands of projects do not amount to food security for Africa,” he said.

  2. Dr Krishna Kaphle says:

    Louise was absolutely right, as scientists we tend to look for higher objectives and have a ‘smaller things are not for me’ attitude. A true scientist is one who brings changes at local level, is proactive in his or her circle at any moment. We tend to see science as a focused goal and a designated objective, not as the catalyst of change we can bring in the space-time we happen to move through. I think modern and future scientists should be sensitive enough to catalyze environmental changes for the betterment in any environment they happen to be into.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Do you mind if I quote a few of your posts as long as I provide credit
    and sources back to your website? My blog site is
    in the exact same area of interest as yours and my users would genuinely benefit
    from a lot of the information you present here. Please let me know if this ok
    with you. Appreciate it!

Comments closed. Read our blogs at www.Scidev.net

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: